I feel the same about it now than I did when it came out. As a collection of songs, it's excellent. As an album, it's rubbish.
I can listen to all twelve songs & I really like them all but not at the same time & certainly not in that order, alot of the songs are similar sounding & the way they're grouped together makes them sound even more so.
Although my opinion of some songs has changed:
On release (out of ten):
Skull, 8
Mama, 6
Black Cloud, 7
Paris, 9
AYNIM, 9
Carol, 7
THPGU, 7
Goodbye, 5
Birthday, 9
Good In Your Time, 8
Sorry, 8
Ok By Myself, 6
Overall: 7/10
Now (out of ten):
Skull, 7
Mama, 8
Black Cloud, 7
Paris, 8
AYNIM, 8
Carol, 7
THPGU, 7
Goodbye, 8
Birthday, 8
Good In Your Time, 7
Sorry, 7
Ok By Myself, 8
7.5/10
The biggest change of opinion being Sorry Doesn't Help compared to I'm Ok By Myself