Holy crap, I adore this song.
I once had a young man (mid thirties-ish, lawyer-type) talk to me for hours about this song. We were waiting in the Q in Oklahoma City. It was one of those odd Q relationships that spontaneously develop just for those few hours. Anyway, he went on and on about it, how much he loved it, it changed his life, etc. I remember thinking, wtf?really? but I kept quiet. I know I've felt that way about other songs, but that one was always just a "skipper" for me.
Fast forward 1 year later. I'm back in my old town, visiting old friends, a few months after I moved away (bad breakup, blah, blah, blah). I'm dreading it.
This song comes on in my car. The "Captain of Games" line is sung, and I'm just wrecked. I'm sobbing so hard I have to pull over and turn the car off.
It's been on my "most played" list ever since.
Rather verbose answer, sorry!